15/10/2026
Topic:
Junctions or SymLinks?
sl23
|
That is a very good point! I didnt think of that! Thanks  |
11 days ago
Topic:
Github SPS Updater - Updates & Add apps
sl23
|
Thanks for the heads up Gian!
First look and I am quite impressed! On opening up I wasnt sure what to expect, but wow, this is quite comprehensive! There are some immediate bugs I have noticed and an immediate FR, but I am pretty busy at present so will test more thoroughly when I get more time. Sorry about that, but Thanks very much for making this ronen1n!!!
1. The PortableApps window has a button under the Add to SyMenu button, no idea what it is, but resizing the window doesn't show it. 2. Similar issue with the Settings dialogue, it shows two buttons at the bottom, but on first opening, I can only see the tops of them, enlarging the window shows that they are Save and Cancel. 3. SPS Community Publisher dialogue shows a link covered by the Account: (not configured) text, likely a settings link to open the settings window for entering the details. 4. PortableApps.com Directory dialogue: This is a FR. It would be useful to have a way to add a new suite as well as selecting a specific suite to install to in the Target Suite drop down. 5. After doing a check now, I found that my ElementalTracker.rar is an unsupported format. Surely RAR format should be supported? Here's the message after clicking Check Now button: Checked 0 definition(s): 0 up to date, 0 without an update source, 0 cannot be updated. No new versions were found.
Errors (1):
• The check failed: 7.0.9: PackerFormat 'zip' does not match the download 'ElementalTracker.rar'
6. And a really bad bug I found is that SyMenu no longer auto-hides on losing focus, I can't hide it, it just keeps being displayed onscreen at all times! Sorry, cant be doing with that one, will have to uninstall until it is fixed! It only seems to do this after opening the plugin. If you don't open the plugin window, it doesnt affect SyMenu operation.
edited by sl23 on 10/11/2026 |
10 days ago
Topic:
Github SPS Updater - Updates & Add apps
sl23
|
Thanks for the really quick response!
Unfortunately, it still doesnt fix the "SyMenu stayed stuck on-screen and stopped auto-hiding on losing focus" issue. Portable Apps and Settings now display correctly. PortableApps into new suite, I would make this clearer, I thought you missed it until I read your Changelog in the OP. Perhaps a tooltip to say type a name for new suite sort of thing.
Otherwise, looks good to me! Great work. When I get time, I will do a thorough test of installing etc. Thanks so much for this! |
10 days ago
Topic:
Github SPS Updater - Updates & Add apps
sl23
|
Sorry, no idea what the issue is, but the focus thing is still not fixed for me. I open the plugin, close it and SyMenu remains onscreen. The only way to hide it is to open something from it, or click the notification icon. |
9 days ago
Topic:
Github SPS Updater - Updates & Add apps
sl23
|
Gianluca wrote:
sl23 wrote:
Sorry, no idea what the issue is, but the focus thing is still not fixed for me. I open the plugin, close it and SyMenu remains onscreen. The only way to hide it is to open something from it, or click the notification icon.
Regarding this bug, the expected behaviour is that the menu closes itself as soon as the plugin's first window opens, not when it closes. BTW, it's a strange issue because I can't reproduce it. The menu behaves correctly on my system whether I open the plugin using the keyboard or the mouse. @sl23: - How is your menu configured? - How do you open it? - Where does it appear on screen? - Do you have any third party tools running that might interfere with window focus or window management? How is it configured? What do you mean, do you want my settings file? I open it via notification icon.
Menu appears bottom right on opening. Not as far as I know, no, there are no 3rd party tools that would interfere with this. I've sent you a gif of the issue Gian.
edited by sl23 on 12/11/2026 |
9 days ago
Topic:
Github SPS Updater - Updates & Add apps
sl23
|
I tried the floating icon, same issue. Also, my Audio Suite plugin doesnt cause this issue when I select it. In fact no other menu selection does this, only that updater plugin. I no longer have that plugin and that link seems to be dead? Says topic not found! |
8 days ago
Topic:
Github SPS Updater - Updates & Add apps
sl23
|
ok, downloaded, same thing, no problem with any other plugin than the github updater one. |
6 days ago
Topic:
Github SPS Updater - Updates & Add apps
sl23
|
ok, tested the new version, it keeps Symenu open while the plugin window is open, but the SyMenu does now hide once I close the plugin window, but I have to click SyMenu then away so it loses focus, or it remains onscreen. Getting there!
I also emailed Gian about this, I wasn't sure if it was a SyMenu or plugin issue, but I have now confirmed it is a plugin issue. When the GithubUpdater is NOT installed SyMenu shows its updates in the SPS Manager as normally would. But installing the plugin then gives gives updates NOT available to SyMenu's SPS Manager. For example, Audacity is happy without the plugin installed at v3.7.9. But install the plugin and I get offered v4.0.2. Which is great on the surface, but the SPS Manager and plugin are then fighting over who is right about the current version, so I then open the SPS Manager and find that now the update is telling that a "new" version is available, but it is a downgrade to v3.7.9!!!
There needs to be a central way to make update checking work, if the plugin is installed, then SyMenu itself should not do the checking, or something like that. But this conflict is confusing for users, that is a definite!
Keep going though, you're doing a great job, just a few wrinkles to sort out!  |
5 days ago
Topic:
Github SPS Updater - Updates & Add apps
sl23
|
If I am honest, I can't say I would use this plugin. Mainly because it is not really clear to me what it is doing and how it is doing it. That said, I think it is a really great idea and should be continued. But at its present state, It is not something I can trust the use of. As Gian pointed out, stability and reliability are paramount. If I don't even know how to use it, why would I trust it not to mess up my apps installations? I'm sorry, but I am not that brave! If I had more time to spare then I would most likely go to the trouble of making specific test folders for this to try it out. But, for me, thats not going to happen.
A simple example... What does it mean when an app states: Official Suite: No upstream source configured? Absolutely no idea what that is supposed to mean?!
Browse PortableApps.com directory... To me this should say something like: Install from PortableApps.com.
I'm guessing it is a translation issue though rather than poor choice of wording. But you've also got: Add App/From PortableApps.com (520+ apps) is this the same as the above, if so, why is it there twice and named two different ways? This causes confusion and confusion in software means one thing to users: uninstall it!
Again, SPS Community Publisher (Check uploader apps) no idea what that means? What does it do, how do I use it, what benefit is it to me? I open this window and am totally clueless what it is for!
What is the Overlays manager and why would I want to use this? Again, it is extremely vague what this is doing. How does all of this affect my apps or the Current SyMenu installation. I'm not prepared to corrupt anything just to test this out. I am not trying to be harsh, I am just trying to point out some basic things that users will see and feel when downloading your plugin. If it is of no immediate use or can't be understood, most won't bother with it, would you?!
Prune menu shortcuts - What is this? Does it delete broken shortcuts? Then it should say that. Merge PortableApps... - Do you mean this will Import PortableApps? Which to me is the typical wording for such a thing. I have a setting called: Patch official suite definitions blah, blah... Yet I am constantly getting upgrades and downgrades showing despite this being ticked by default. I have changed no settings or touched anything since installing the plugin other than open windows. I open the normal SPS Manager and get asked to update three apps, as I explained to Gian in an email: Audacity, for example, is asking to upgrade, I do so, then I am again asked to downgrade, then upgrade, downgrade, wtf?! Uninstalling the plugin stops this behaviour. I find the plugin interesting and would like to advise much as I can, but these issues need resolving for it to be of any use.
Don't be disheartened by my comments, I mean only to give instructional criticism, not pessimistic abuse. I am trying to make you see how I see it so you can try to make the plugin easier to use and less buggy. I hope you can resolve these things because it looks good and is a great idea.
I will also say, although Gian is right, I do see the merits of having this plugin cater to the default suites. There are users who do not want auto updates, do not use SyMenu in a traditional way, but may want to use this plugin in some other manual way, and that could be where it becomes useful to take control of the default suites. Or if Gian stops being interested and no longer updates the default suites, it could happen! Many possibilities, so this could replace that. Tbh, this could potentially even replace the way Gian works and make it easier for him to continue updating the default suites much more easily, who knows?
EDIT: Just looked at the first post again! Ok, some of my criticisms are explained there. I would suggest having a Help option that opens a window to explain what things are, like in your OP. Or, and this may be better, in each window, have a dedicated area at the bottom that shows tooltips when hovering over things. Then the manual is integrated and better explains what things are.
edited by sl23 on 16/11/2026 |
5 days ago
Topic:
Github SPS Updater - Updates & Add apps
sl23
|
Thats ok, I understand, you cant please everyone all the time!  No offense meant, I thought you were working alone and intended to keep it that way.
It's not that its wanted to be to my liking specifically, its that when designing an app, you have to make it foolproof, if you dont design it like that, how can you expect it to be popular?! That is the basis of what I said.
I get there is a translation barrier, understandable, but if you want to share something, as can be seen by just about any other app in existence, it has to be legible in English, if it isn't people tak eit the wrong way or plain misunderstand what it is meant to do. It's a fantastic idea!
Gian has spent over twenty years on SyMenu, isn't that enough? I get you think this should be integrated, but if you are vibe-coding, one thing to learn, stick at it! Because that is one issue many have with us and it is a valid point. AI is new and everyone wants to be a developer, it is not an easy thing, to do. The hardest thing is sticking through it when it gets tough, and now, this is getting tough, don't give up, you're doing great. As I said, if you want to share it needs better wording and tooltips to explain in the app. That would go a long way to helping users understand how this works without havin gto look things up everytime they want to use it.
Anyway, thanks for the effort 
Is the source on Github? Are you willing to share it? Maybe I can take a look and try help, not sure exactly when, I am trying to create a suite of AudioPlugins at present, and only on my third!
edited by sl23 on 16/11/2026 |